Top TV Shows That Defied Critics and Won Over the Audience

November 11, 2025

Every cinephile loves a good story arc. While some stories get justice from critics, many don’t. Yes, we are talking about the TV shows that didn’t get much attention from critics and rather found hollow inside. But the same shows were loved by the audience, who did them justice with their ratings and rankings. At VirtuousReviews, a highly trusted third-party reviewing platform, you will find a range of entertainment productions reviewed by an audience that’ll do justice to your time. So choose the highly rated and ranked shows by the audience without focusing too much on the critical evaluation. Here, you will find the most authentic and genuine reviews from customers that make the content binge-worthy! So let’s get into it.

Top TV Shows that Critics Hate But Audience Loved: Which One of These Have You Watched?

#1: Emily in Paris on Netflix

Emily in Paris is a drama series starring Lily Collins available on Netflix. The critics of the show found it “hollow”, but the moment it landed on Netflix, the show created a buzz like no other. Audience showered so much love on the show that it made it to the top 10 list in more than 40 countries. It has become one of the best original series on Netflix, but according to the critics, all it entails is pretty faces wearing pretty clothes and escapism, which is widely a millennial plus Gen Z thing!

#2: Manifest on Netflix

Starring Josh Dallas and Melissa Roxburgh, Manifest is one of the highly liked fiction series on Netflix. The plot of the show revolves around the mysterious disappearance of a flight that returns after 5 years, but only a few hours have passed for passengers who battled a storm before making a safe landing. The plot of the series itself is so gripping that the audience couldn’t help but shower it with a lot of love.

#3: 2 Broke Girls on Prime Video

The popular sitcom series 2 Broke Girls is as funny as it gets if your sense of humour can bear jokes surrounding racial and sexual stereotypes. For the same reason, though, the show fell short in matching the “wow” criteria of critics. Sure, compared to popular sitcoms like Modern Family and Friends, the show falls short for critics, but it tells a true story of the financial struggle of two girls trying to make it big in New York City.

Bottom Line?

Choose VirtuousReviews for finding the most genuine and top-ranked movies and TV shows. Customer reviews play a crucial role in guiding the audience in deciding where they should invest their time and money. Reviews serve as a valuable form of peer validation, allowing you to find other reviewers who appreciated the content as much as others did. No matter what critics say, invest your time in meaningful content.

Name:

Email:

Comment: